Narnia vs. Harry Potter

January 2nd, 2006

Narnia Hogwart's

Loads of magic and other pagan material in it.

Loads of magic and other pagan material in it.

Christmas is celebrated.

Christmas is celebrated.

Watched over by an all-knowing God-figure named Aslan who created the setting, punishes the bad, and covers the heroes' butts.

Watched over by an all-knowing God-figure named Dumbledore who created the setting, punishes the bad, and covers the heroes' butts.

A tempting devil-figure named Janis.

A tempting devil-figure named Voldemort.

More than one Savior figure who come from a humble setting to save everything from the aformentioned devil-figure; namely, the kids who stepped through the closet, and Aslan from an angle.

One Savior figure who comes from a humble setting to save everything from the aformentioned devil-figure; namely Harry Potter.

Aslan has a bunch of disciples, oddly similar to Jesus's own.

Harry has a bunch of buddies and followers, oddly similar to Jesus' disciples.

Dead people (dormant statues) get reaminated.

Dead people roaming the halls is a regular occurence in Hogwart's.

Contains a traitorious Judas-figure named Edmund who sells our heroes out to the devil-figure.

Contains a traitorious Judas-figure named Quirrell (later Scabbers) who sells our hero out to the devil-figure.

Contains a blood-red cordial that heals everything; perhaps symbolic of the blood Jesus sacrificed on the cross to heal us of our sins.

Contains the tears from a blood-red pheonix, that heals everything; perhaps symbolic of the blood Jesus sacrificed on the cross to heal us of our sins.

Aslan dies and comes back to life.

Harry dies and comes back to life.

Aslan's ressurection comes with the stone table breaking, alluding to the breaking of the Temple at Jesus's death (Matthew 27: 50-53, KJV.)

Harry breaks open a stone Chamber of Secrets.

Aslan leaves in the end of the movie with the promise of return, just like Jesus promised.

Harry leaves at the end of each year, with the promise of returning.

Emphasizes on friendship and unity.

Emphasizes on friendship and unity.

Overall a story about good repeatedly triumphing over evil.

Overall a story about good repeatedly triumphing over evil.

Is hailed as a Christian allegory. Makes perfect sense; just look at the similarities to the Bible.

...isn't.

 Back to Ramblings...

Jack Chick comics were devoted to this page. Fenris Designs site, logo, and images © 2006-2007 Fenris, all rights reserved.